Hydrogen production from fossil resources is CO2-intensive, yet these feedstocks account for 96% of global hydrogen production; while electrified H2 synthesis from water is potentially less carbon-intensive but remains electricity-intensive. A (cradle-to-gate) carbon-negative alternative is to split partially-reduced terrestrial biomass—which incorporates CO2 from the atmosphere—into separated streams of H2 for use and CO2 for sequestration. Unfortunately, biomass thermochemical gasification, which uses O2, generally requires > 280 MJ/kg H2 because of a approximately < 50% biomass-to-H2 yield. The balance of biomass becomes biochar and H2O. Here we report biomass electrosplitting, wherein a membrane reactor produces H2 on the cathodic gas stream and CO2 (for sequestration) on the anode. Unfortunately, in initial studies employing known catalysts, we found that the full cell voltage drifted upward over the course of a few hours’ operation. Only by developing catalysts that enhance metal:hydroxyl group binding to stabilize C3 adsorbates (Raman + DFT) were we able to lower the reaction barrier to the rate-limiting (and hence full-cell-voltage-determining) step—glycerol oxidation to glyceric acid. We report that when separated streams of H2 and CO2 (each 98 mol%) enter the system, electrical energy consumption drops to 205 MJ/kg H2. When we analyze life cycle GHG emissions and cost as a function of candidate feedstocks and sources of electricity we identify two cases of interest. Firstly, solar electricity plus either soy glycerol or corn stover glucose feedstocks lead to cradle-to-gate GHG emissions of −8 and −10 kgCO2/kgH2, respectively, with a plant-gate levelized cost <= $2/kg H2. Secondly, because of the low production GHG emissions, soy glycerol or corn stover glucose achieve negative net emissions (−0.1 and −2 kgCO2/kgH2, respectively) even when powered using electricity having the carbon intensity of present-day US mix.