Electrochemical CO2 reduction (CO2R), utilizing Cu-based catalysts, is a technology capable of converting CO2 into valuable multi-carbon products, such as ethylene and ethanol, using the simple inputs of CO2, water, and electricity. Current CO2R systems utilize ultra-pure deionized water as the electrolyte solvent to maintain high catalytic performance but are not competitive with industrial chemical processes. Operation in real-world water sources provides a potential pathway to improved economic competitiveness of CO2R systems. In this work, we investigated the consequences of ppm concentrations of multivalent cationic impurities (Ca2+ and Mg2+) commonly encountered in abundant water sources (e.g., seawater, tap water) on CO2R performance. We show that these ions and their mixtures can negatively affect Cu-based CO2R performance, promoting loss of total activity and selectivity towards CO2R products. Through the stepwise addition of these ions to the electrolyte, we investigated the potential influence of ionic impurities on Cu catalyst reconstruction and the resultant consequences on CO2R performance.