Many studies have established a major effect of nanoscale confinement on the glass transition temperature (
Tg) of polystyrene (PS), most commonly in thin films with one or two free surfaces. Here, we characterize smaller yet significant intrinsic size effects (in the absence of free surfaces or significant attractive polymer-substrate interactions) on the
Tg and fragility of linear PS (see
J. Chem. Phys. 2017, 146, 203323). Melt infiltration of various molecular weights (MWs) of PS into anodic aluminum oxide (AAO) templates is used to create nanorods supported on AAO with rod diameter (
d) ranging from 24 to 210 nm. The
Tg (both as
Tg,onset and fictive temperature) and fragility values are characterized by differential scanning calorimetry. No intrinsic size effect is observed for 30 kg/mol PS in template-supported nanorods with
d = 24 nm. However, effects on
Tg are present for PS nanorods with
Mn and
Mw ⥠~ 175 kg/mol, with effects increasing in magnitude with increasing MW. For example, in 24-nm-diameter template-supported nanorods,
Tg,rod â
Tg,bulk = -2.0 to -2.5 °C for PS with
Mn = 175 kg/mol and
Mw = 182 kg/mol, and
Tg,rod â
Tg,bulk = ~ -8 °C for PS with
Mn = 929 kg/mol and
Mw = 1420 kg/mol. In general, reductions in
Tg occur when
d ⤠~ 2
Rg, where
Rg is the bulk polymer radius of gyration. Thus, intrinsic size effects are significant when rod diameter is smaller than the diameter (2
Rg) associated with the spherical volume pervaded by coils in bulk. We hypothesize that the
Tg reduction occurs when chain segment packing frustration is sufficiently perturbed by confinement in the nanorods. This explanation is supported by observed reductions in fragility with increasing extent of confinement. We also explain why these small intrinsic size effects do not contradict reports that the
Tg-confinement effect in supported PS films with one free surface exhibits little or no MW dependence. This point can be understood by comparing template-supported nanorod and thin film
Tg reductions at a similar characteristic length scale,
t*. For PS nanorods with
dm = 63 nm or
t* = 15.8 nm, as measured by DSC there is no reduction in
Tg relative to bulk response when
Mn and
Mw ⤠~500 kg/mol, and
Tg,rod â
Tg,bulk = ~ -2 °C for PS with
Mn = 929 kg/mol and
Mw = 1420 kg/mol. As determined by ellipsometry, supported PS films with thickness of 16 nm (
t* = 16 nm) exhibit
Tg,film â
Tg,bulk = ~ -19 °C (
Europhys. Letter.1994, 27,59). Thus, at MWs of PS most commonly used in studies of
Tg-confinement effects in the presence of a free surface, intrinsic size effects contribute nothing within error to the measured effect; at extremely high PS MW, the contribution of intrinsic size effects is only a very small percentage of the reported
Tg reduction.
The characterization of intrinsic size effect on Tg is being extended to a crosslinked, supported PS nanorod system. Linear precursor polystyrene-co-vinylbenzoycyclobutene (VBCB) nanorods with Mn = 30 kg/mol exhibit no intrinsic size effect on Tg, where d > 2Rg even in template with 24-nm pore diameter. Upon crosslinking the VBCB units, the network structure exhibit effectively infinite MW. The comparison of Tg-confinement effects in linear and crosslinked PS nanorods is being studied and will be discussed.