Understanding the surface reaction mechanisms, the nature of surface reaction sites, and the chemical physics behind differently-promoted hydrogen transfer steps in the photocatalytic reduction of CO
2 and H
2O is critical to enable the systematic design and improvement of catalysts for the production of higher hydrocarbons and oxygenates from solar energy. Our recent studies indicate that the product distribution, e.g., H
2 and CO vs. CH
4, in the photocatalytic reduction of CO
2 is connected to two distinct types of hydrogen transfer steps â?? electrochemically-coupled H-transfer and excited-electron mediated H-transfer. Presence of protonic hydrogen (H
+) on photocatalyst surface correlated with electrochemically-coupled H-transfer steps to preferentially produce H
2. The electrochemical steps for CO production in this case likely follow similar chemical physics. On the contrary, when metallic hydrogen (H
0) is encountered, results suggest that the transfer of H
0 to surface-bound organic fragments occur via excited electron induced vibrational excitation of the uncharged H
0, resulting in production of CH
4. A clear connection was observed between the presence of H
0 on surface and CH
4 evolution, and conversely, the presence of H
+ on surface and H
2 evolution. In our photoreaction experiments, we were able to modify the catalyst selectivity from CH
4 to H
2 evolution by transforming the adsorbed metallic H
0 into protonic H
+ by incorporating more electronegative reaction sites into the photocatalyst surface. Theoretical calculation results suggested a shift from excited electron-mediated H
0 transfer phenomena to electrochemical H-transfer phenomena resulting in H
2 evolution. Understanding the electronic nature of adsorbed hydrogen on photocatalyst surface and the nature of surface reaction sites will potentially lend insights into tuning the overall photocatalytic product distribution, which may lead to the sustainable production of higher hydrocarbons and oxygenates from CO
2 and H
2O using solar radiation.